Comparing Subscription Boxes: Which One is Worth Your Money?

Comparing Subscription Boxes: Which One is Worth Your Money?

Comparing Subscription Boxes: Which One is Worth Your Money?

Subscription boxes have taken the world by storm, offering a convenient and exciting way to discover new products. From beauty and fitness to food and hobbies, there’s a subscription box for nearly every interest. But with so many options available, it can be challenging to determine which one offers the best value for your money. This article provides an in-depth comparison of some of the most popular subscription boxes to help you make an informed decision.


Subscription boxes have revolutionised the way we shop and discover new products. They offer a curated selection of items delivered right to your door, often at a fraction of the retail price. However, not all subscription boxes are created equal. Some offer great value and high-quality products, while others may leave you feeling disappointed. In this article, we will compare various subscription boxes across different categories, including beauty, fitness, food, and hobbies, to determine which ones are worth your money.

Beauty Subscription Boxes

1. Birchbox

Birchbox is one of the pioneers in the beauty subscription box industry. For £10 per month, you receive five sample-sized beauty products tailored to your preferences. Birchbox partners with well-known and emerging brands, offering a mix of skincare, haircare, and makeup products.

  • Pros: Affordable, personalised, and includes a variety of products.
  • Cons: Sample sizes may be too small for some, and you may receive repeated products over time.

Each month, Birchbox sends a combination of products ranging from new launches to cult favourites. Subscribers fill out a beauty profile, which helps Birchbox customise the products to suit individual skin types, hair types, and beauty preferences. The company also offers a rewards programme where you earn points for purchases and reviews, which can be redeemed for full-sized products in their online store.

2. Glossybox

Glossybox offers a monthly subscription for £13.25, including five deluxe-sized beauty products. The box focuses on premium brands and occasionally includes full-sized items.

  • Pros: High-quality products, occasional full-sized items, and attractive packaging.
  • Cons: Slightly more expensive than some competitors, and the product selection may not always match your preferences.

Glossybox is known for its luxurious packaging and attention to detail. Each box is beautifully designed and often follows a theme, adding to the unboxing experience. The brands featured in Glossybox are typically higher-end, offering subscribers a chance to try luxury products at a fraction of the cost. Additionally, Glossybox frequently collaborates with well-known beauty influencers and brands for exclusive, limited-edition boxes.

3. Lookfantastic Beauty Box

For £15 per month, the Lookfantastic Beauty Box delivers six beauty products, often full-sized, from well-known brands. Subscribers also receive a copy of the Elle magazine.

  • Pros: Excellent value for money, full-sized products, and a free magazine.
  • Cons: Slightly more expensive, and not all products may be to your taste.

Lookfantastic stands out for its inclusion of full-sized products and its partnership with Elle magazine, which adds extra value to each box. The subscription often includes skincare, haircare, makeup, and wellness products, providing a comprehensive beauty experience. Lookfantastic also offers a loyalty scheme where subscribers earn points that can be used for discounts on future purchases.


If you are looking for an affordable beauty subscription with a variety of products, Birchbox is a great choice. For those willing to spend a bit more for higher quality and occasional full-sized items, Glossybox and Lookfantastic Beauty Box are excellent options. Birchbox offers the best personalisation, Glossybox delivers a luxurious experience, and Lookfantastic provides excellent value with its full-sized products and magazine inclusion.

Fitness Subscription Boxes

1. FabFitFun

FabFitFun offers a quarterly subscription box for £49.99, featuring a mix of fitness, wellness, beauty, and lifestyle products. Each box includes 8-10 full-sized items, and members can customise some of the items in their box.

  • Pros: High-quality, full-sized products, customisation options, and a wide variety of items.
  • Cons: Higher price point, and you only receive four boxes per year.

FabFitFun is renowned for its diverse product selection, covering multiple categories such as fitness, beauty, wellness, and lifestyle. The customisation feature allows subscribers to select certain items from a list of options, ensuring they receive products they are most interested in. Each box often has a seasonal theme, and the value of the products typically exceeds £200. Additionally, FabFitFun offers access to exclusive sales and a supportive community of subscribers.

2. MuscleBox

MuscleBox is a monthly subscription box focused on fitness enthusiasts. For £24.99 per month, you receive a selection of fitness apparel, snacks, and workout accessories tailored to your fitness goals.

  • Pros: Affordable, targeted towards fitness enthusiasts, and includes a variety of useful items.
  • Cons: Some items may not be suitable for all fitness levels, and the value can vary from month to month.

MuscleBox caters specifically to those serious about their fitness journey. Each box is curated to help subscribers stay motivated and achieve their fitness goals. The items range from high-quality workout apparel and accessories to protein-packed snacks and supplements. MuscleBox also offers tailored options such as Miss MuscleBox for women and ProteinBox for those focused on their nutritional intake.

3. YogaClub

YogaClub offers a monthly subscription for £59, providing high-quality yoga apparel curated based on your style and size preferences. Each box includes a complete outfit from premium brands at a fraction of the retail price.

  • Pros: High-quality apparel, personalised to your style and size, and excellent value for money.
  • Cons: Higher price point, and limited to yoga apparel.

YogaClub stands out for its focus on premium yoga apparel. Subscribers fill out a style quiz, and each month they receive a coordinated outfit from top brands such as Manduka, Teeki, and Beyond Yoga. The value of the apparel usually exceeds £100, making it a cost-effective way to update your workout wardrobe. Additionally, YogaClub donates a yoga class to a child in need for every box purchased, adding a charitable aspect to the subscription.


For a comprehensive fitness and lifestyle box, FabFitFun is an excellent choice, offering a wide variety of high-quality products. If you are specifically looking for fitness gear and snacks, MuscleBox provides good value. For yoga enthusiasts, YogaClub offers premium apparel at a significant discount. Each of these boxes caters to different aspects of the fitness world, so choose based on your specific needs and preferences.

Food Subscription Boxes

1. Graze

Graze offers a weekly snack subscription box for £3.99, featuring a selection of healthy and delicious snacks tailored to your preferences. Each box contains four snack portions, perfect for on-the-go snacking.

  • Pros: Affordable, healthy snacks, and personalised to your taste preferences.
  • Cons: Portions may be small for some, and the selection can become repetitive over time.

Graze’s appeal lies in its focus on healthy and natural ingredients. Subscribers fill out a taste profile, and Graze uses this information to select snacks that match their preferences. The snacks range from nuts and seeds to dried fruits and flapjacks, all free from artificial colours, flavours, and preservatives. The convenience of having portion-controlled snacks delivered weekly makes Graze a popular choice for health-conscious individuals.

2. HelloFresh

HelloFresh is a meal kit subscription service that delivers pre-portioned ingredients and recipes to your door. Prices start at £3.25 per serving, and you can choose from a variety of meal plans to suit your dietary preferences.

  • Pros: Convenient, high-quality ingredients, and easy-to-follow recipes.
  • Cons: More expensive than traditional grocery shopping, and you need to prepare the meals yourself.

HelloFresh simplifies meal planning and preparation by providing everything you need to cook delicious meals at home. Subscribers choose from a rotating menu of recipes, including options for vegetarians, families, and those seeking quick meals. The ingredients are fresh and often locally sourced, and the step-by-step recipes are designed to be easy to follow, even for novice cooks. HelloFresh also offers flexibility in terms of delivery frequency and the ability to skip weeks as needed.

3. SnackCrate

SnackCrate offers a monthly subscription box featuring snacks from around the world. For £14 per month, you receive a selection of snacks from a different country each month, along with a guide to the snacks and their origins.

  • Pros: Unique and interesting snacks, educational, and great for adventurous eaters.
  • Cons: Slightly more expensive, and not all snacks may suit your taste.

SnackCrate provides an exciting way to explore global flavours from the comfort of your home. Each month’s box highlights a different country, offering a curated selection of snacks that showcase the region’s culinary diversity. The included guide provides information about the snacks and cultural insights, making SnackCrate both a fun and educational experience. It’s perfect for those who love to try new foods and learn about different cultures.


Graze is perfect for those looking for affordable and healthy snacks. HelloFresh is ideal for those who enjoy cooking and want the convenience of meal kits. SnackCrate offers a fun and educational experience for those who love trying new foods from around the world. Each food subscription box has its unique appeal, so consider your dietary needs and interests when choosing the right one for you.

Hobby Subscription Boxes

1. Loot Crate

Loot Crate offers a monthly subscription box for £24.99, featuring a curated selection of geek and gamer items, including collectibles, apparel, and accessories. Each box follows a specific theme and includes exclusive items.

  • Pros: High-quality and exclusive items, great for geeks and gamers, and themed boxes.
  • Cons: More expensive, and the theme may not always match your interests.

Loot Crate has built a loyal following by delivering exclusive, high-quality items that cater to fans of pop culture, gaming, and geek fandoms. Each box is centred around a theme, such as superheroes, sci-fi, or fantasy, and includes items like T-shirts, figurines, and collectibles. Loot Crate often partners with major franchises, ensuring that subscribers receive unique, licensed merchandise that can’t be found elsewhere. The excitement of unboxing and discovering the theme each month is a big part of the appeal.

2. Maker Crate

Maker Crate is a monthly subscription box for £29.99, focused on DIY and craft projects. Each box includes materials and instructions for a creative project, suitable for adults and older teens.

  • Pros: High-quality materials, fun and educational projects, and suitable for various skill levels.
  • Cons: Higher price point, and you may not enjoy all types of projects.

Maker Crate is perfect for those who enjoy hands-on creativity. Each box is designed to inspire and teach new skills, ranging from painting and knitting to woodworking and jewellery making. The detailed instructions and high-quality materials ensure that the projects are both enjoyable and satisfying. Maker Crate also encourages subscribers to share their creations and connect with a community of fellow makers, adding a social aspect to the crafting experience.

3. Book of the Month

Book of the Month is a monthly subscription box for £11.99, offering a selection of five new and notable books. Subscribers choose one book to receive each month, and additional books can be added for a discounted price.

  • Pros: Affordable, great selection of books, and flexible options.
  • Cons: Limited to book lovers, and you may not always find a book you like among the selections.

Book of the Month curates a list of five carefully selected books each month, spanning various genres and styles. Subscribers read detailed descriptions and reviews before choosing their book, ensuring they pick something they’ll enjoy. The subscription often features debut authors, providing an opportunity to discover new voices in literature. Book of the Month also offers an active online community where members can discuss their reads and participate in book-related events.


Loot Crate is perfect for geeks and gamers who love collectibles and themed items. Maker Crate is ideal for those who enjoy DIY and craft projects. Book of the Month is a fantastic option for book lovers looking for new reads. Each hobby box caters to a specific interest, making it easier to find the perfect subscription based on your passions.


Choosing the right subscription box depends on your interests, budget, and preferences. Each box offers unique benefits and experiences, so it’s essential to consider what matters most to you. Whether you’re looking for beauty products, fitness gear, healthy snacks, or a fun hobby, there’s a subscription box out there that offers great value for your money. We hope this comparison helps you make an informed decision and find the perfect subscription box to suit your needs.

Subscription boxes provide a delightful way to discover new products and enjoy a curated experience. With options ranging from affordable snack boxes to luxurious beauty packages, there’s something for everyone. Take the time to explore different boxes, read reviews, and consider what aligns best with your lifestyle and preferences. Happy unboxing!